Thursday, November 12, 2026

Beyond the Bookshelf: When Access to a Collection Isn't Enough

Citation:

Fagan, M. K. (2024). Children's access to books, libraries, and storybook reading: Survey of mothers at a family homeless shelter. Urban Education, 59(4), 1106–1131. https://doi.org/10.1177/00420859211073901


Summary:

One of the recurring themes throughout my MLIS studies has been the distinction between providing access to information and creating meaningful opportunities for people to use it. Mary K. Fagan's research on children's access to books and libraries while experiencing homelessness offers an especially revealing example of this distinction.

Fagan (2024) surveyed mothers of 24 children living in a family homeless shelter and 27 children living in nearby housed families. The study examined access to children's books, public library use, library card ownership, and shared storybook reading. The results demonstrated significant disparities in the availability of books and library participation. Among families experiencing homelessness, 71% did not have library cards, and only 33% of mothers reported reading to their children daily, compared with 73% of mothers in the comparison group.

Although the study involved a relatively small sample from one urban community, its findings raise important questions about how libraries understand accessibility. A public library may possess an excellent children's collection, but the existence of those materials does not necessarily mean that families experiencing housing instability can take advantage of them.

Transportation difficulties, identification requirements, unfamiliarity with library services, and the challenges of maintaining stable routines can create barriers that traditional collection management practices may overlook.

What I find particularly compelling is how this research connects to the distinction between collection development and connection development that we have been exploring in INFO 266. Collection development asks whether the library possesses appropriate resources for its community. Connection development asks whether those resources can actually reach the people who need them.

For families experiencing homelessness, that distinction can be significant. Partnerships with shelters, mobile library services, flexible borrowing policies, and outreach programs may accomplish more than simply purchasing additional materials for an existing collection.

Fagan's study does not directly evaluate these interventions, but it provides evidence of the access disparities that such programs might address. From a collection management perspective, the larger lesson is that circulation statistics and collection size cannot independently demonstrate equitable service. Families who cannot easily visit the library or obtain borrowing privileges may remain invisible in the very statistics used to guide collection development.

Perhaps we should be asking not only whether our collections reflect the communities we serve, but whether our services create realistic opportunities for those communities to engage with them. After all, a library's responsibility does not end when a book is placed on a shelf. In many respects, that is where the work begins.


Tuesday, November 10, 2026

A Collection Can Be Full and Still Leave a Child Out

 Name: Schwab, Kayla

Citation

IFLA Library Services to Children and Young Adults Section. (2018). IFLA guidelines for library services to children aged 0–18 (C. Rankin, Ed.; 2nd ed., version 1.1.1). International Federation of Library Associations and Institutions.

Read Here

Summary

The IFLA Guidelines for Library Services to Children Aged 0–18 emphasize the importance of developing library collections that reflect the diverse needs of children and their communities. The guidelines explain that collection development should consider more than the number of books available. Librarians should also consider accessibility, cultural representation, different reading abilities, and the formats in which materials are offered.

One particularly important recommendation is that children's collections should include materials representing different cultures, languages, family structures, identities, and abilities. The guidelines also discuss providing resources in multiple formats, including audiobooks, Braille materials, sensory materials, and digital resources.

The document encourages libraries to involve children and families in decisions about their collections and services. Rather than assuming what children need, librarians should actively listen to the communities they serve.

Evaluation and Reflection

What stands out to me about these guidelines is the difference between having a large collection and having a collection that genuinely serves everyone.

A library might have thousands of books, but what happens when a child cannot find a character who looks like them, a story that reflects their family, or a book in a format they can access? Having a large collection does not automatically mean that the collection is inclusive.

I also appreciate the emphasis on listening to children. Librarians have professional knowledge about collection development, but the children using the library have valuable perspectives about what is missing.

Although these guidelines focus on public library services for children, I believe many of the principles apply to school libraries as well. One practical way to apply them would be to evaluate a collection for gaps in representation and accessibility while inviting students to suggest materials they would like to see.

One limitation is that some recommendations may be difficult for libraries with small budgets, limited staff, or restricted access to specialized materials. However, even small changes could make a meaningful difference.

My biggest takeaway is that collection development should not just be about what a library owns. It should also be about who can use those resources and who feels represented by them.


Monday, November 2, 2026

Curated Collection from Votes

 

Fogelberg, Rachel

 

Heisserer-Miller, R. A. (2023). A Community Curated Collection in an Academic Library: Empowering Students Through Collection Development. NASIG Proceedings, 37. https://doi.org/10.3998/nasig.4031

 

Summary

This is a presentation given at the 2022 annual NASIG conference about two initiatives at an academic library. The purpose of the programs was to involve students in collection development to overcome decreased funding and a need for student engagement. The first program asked students for subject areas that they wanted to add to the library collection that would interest them, such as mental health. The subject areas were then voted on by the students and new materials were added about that subject. The second program was paid for through a grant. Student groups, like the National Student Speech Language and Hearing Association, created a list of materials and submitted their application. While some faculty did not like the initiatives, the presenter said that the programs offered new ways for library engagement in diversity, equity, and outreach.

 

Evaluation

These program ideas sound exciting and could work with a little adaptation in many types of libraries, such as school libraries, especially with high schoolers, and public libraries. The programs are an effective way to get both patrons and the community involved with collection development. In addition to growing physical materials, the programs could ask for other items to create a new collection, whatever the community requested. For example, a “library of things” could be created from donations from the neighborhood based on common needs from a suggestion box. This idea works for school, academic, and public libraries.

Tuesday, October 27, 2026

Mapping IDEA in collection development: A scoping and bibliometric review

Name:

Slutzky, Erin

Citation: 

Torres, E. M., Jr., & Peñaflor, J. D. (2026). Mapping IDEA in collection development: A scoping and bibliometric review. IFLA Journal, 52(2), 375-387. https://doi.org/10.1177/03400352251378765


Summary:

This research analyzed studies from 2001 to 2026 that focused on creating a more inclusive and accessible collection in all types of libraries. The study found that, although progress is being made, it is largely limited to Western libraries geographically. In addition, these studies are mainly librarian-focused rather than user-focused, so underrepresented groups are often being overlooked and not heard. The author argues for increased representation, geographically and socially for underserved communities within this research. They claim that the research is imperative to the work librarians do to create equitable access points to inclusive  information.


Evaluation:

I thought this was a very informative article for those attempting to increase DEI representation across all collections. Its evaluation of progress is astute and helpful as well to librarians or future librarians as we need to remember to focus our attention on user-centric goals by listening to those who are underrepresented within our communities. I also appreciate that the article ties in inclusivity to our overall goal as libraries to provide equitable access to information. This illustrates that DEI and inclusive practices are vital to the successful fulfillment of our goals as information hubs.


Monday, May 11, 2026

Ask the Comics Librarians: Small Spaces

Mayer, Shu

Shannan, Meredith. (2022, February 6). Ask the comics librarians: Small spaces. No Flying No Tights. https://noflyingnotights.com/blog/2022/02/06/ask-the-comics-librarians-small-spaces/ 

Summary:

In this article, two librarians discuss how important space is in libraries and how to most effectively display, collect for, weed, and curate small comic/graphic novel collections. They recommend shelving by book title and curating for the community rather than what is deemed 'popular' by recommended book lists. They also recommend being aggressive in weeding smaller collections since space is premium and promoting them more aggressively since less people may know it is present.

Evaluation:

Overall this is a good article for someone who is unsure where to start when setting up a new collection in a limited space. Or potentially, someone moving an existing small collection from being spread out across the library into one consolidated space. It is an article geared towards comic/graphic novel collections-- as the entire noflyingnotights website is specifically for librarians who need help with comic/graphic collections-- but the advice for smaller collections can be easily generalized. 

 Collection Development: The Basics and Beyond

 Clara Shuler

 Vnuk, R. (2015, July 22) Collection development; The basics and beyond. [Video] YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3IEVL8WV73o
 

This video is a recording of a lecture by Rebecca Vnuk on the subject of the basics of Collection development, offered to MLIS graduate students and professionals as a proffessional development opportunity to fill in the gaps for those whos academic program did not give them a strong basis. It is somewhat dated in its references, but provides an excellent, broad overview of the practicalities of collection development, delivered in an an extremely personable and engaging format. It provides some sorely needed practical context for some of the more theoretical research being done on collection development practices. 

A Review of Citation Analysis Methodologies for Collection Management.

Busath, Kellie


Hoffmann, K., & Doucette, L. (2012). A review of citation analysis methodologies for collection management. College & research libraries, 73(4), 321-335.


This article reviewed how multiple institutions went about doing a citation analysis for collection development purposes. Citation analysis is reviewing the citations used by faculty at the institution to see what areas of expertise needed to be accommodated by the library. It included collecting materials that were listed in citations if they were not already acquired by the library and also collecting materials linked to the citations used. This would be done by reviewing citations and then researching what other articles or resources had used that same citation. The citations were also reviewed to spot trends in research for the institution, collecting materials that would aid in future research endeavors. The article itself was a review of the different methodologies that each institution would use for their citation analysis. It was found that many institutions did not have a set methodology, but instead, everyone at the institution would go about it a little differently. Some common things that librarians would look at when doing a citation analysis was:

  1. Type of resource

  2. Age of resource

  3. Frequency of citation

  4. Presence of resource in the library


I found this article very interesting. I had heard about doing a citation analysis, but I wasn’t quite clear on the purpose or method behind it. I learned a lot about both! Doing a citation analysis could be helpful for research institutions, depending on the goals of your library. I belong to a research institution, but our collections policy is to only collect for undergraduate curriculum so faculty research interests may or may not align with that curriculum. In addition, I am currently trying to collect for our Communications College and the faculty there do not have the same publishing requirements as the rest of the University, so it is harder to tell what their interests are. Still the methodologies in this article give good insight into doing this type of analysis for collection development.




Digitizing and 3D Printing the Collection at the Smithsonian Museum



 Escobedo, Xavier


Adam Savage’s Tested. (2019, September 2). Digitizing Objects from Smithsonian’s Enormous Collection! YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cgqv-MKbogQ


https://3d.si.edu/explore


Summary

The Smithsonian has 155 million artifacts in its collection and less than 1% is ever on display. The Smithsonian is now scanning many items from their collection that would never be seen by the public, and uploading a digitized copy on their website. The public can interact with these artifacts on the Smithsonian 3D digitization page, as well as download 3D printing information so they may print the artifact with their own machine. Artifacts are digitized are by photogrammetry, structure light scanning, and with the FARO Design Scanarm, which shoots lasers to capture the geometry of an object. Educators are able to print their own replica of historical objects and use the 3D printed model for instructional purposes. Inquisitive individuals can comb through the collection and have a fun time learning about various historical artifacts. It is a great way to showcase the Smithsonian’s extensive collection that would otherwise go unseen by the public. 


Evaluation

Digitizing the historical artifacts in the Smithsonian collection further preserves the materials by making them available to the public through the internet. While some historical artifacts may eventually disintegrate, they will now be forever preserved in their digital form and may even have their replicas 3D printed for future generations. Digitizing and 3D printing are great ways for the public to interact with objects that would normally be behind a glass or stored in a warehouse. The bulk of the collection that is stored and never made available to the public now has a new breath of life and helps the museum stay relevant through online visitors.

The tools used for digitizing materials are expensive, but it would be interesting to see if other museums begin digitizing their collection for the public. 

Maybe... just maybe... those European museums could digitize and 3D print their entire collection and eventually give back all the original artifacts that were stolen. 


Pretty cool technology though, jokes aside. 




Sustainability in Library Collection Development: Introducing a Green Audit Template

Jessie Major 

Citation: 

McCord, D., Cassady, S., Roman, P., Cato, J., & Mantz, E. (2025). Sustainability in Library Collection Development: Introducing a Green Audit Template. Canadian Journal of Academic Librarianship / Revue Canadienne De Bibliothéconomie Universitaire, 11, 1–18. https://doi.org/10.33137/cjal-rcbu.v11.43852   

Summary:

This project presents an original 'Green Audit' template to determine how environmentally sustainable an academic publisher is. Publishers are judged based on environmental practices, current impact, and future commitments. A case study of 16 international publishers examines the availability of information, geographic differences, commitments and compliance, materials, transportation, and infrastructure. The results of such a Green Audit can help LIS professionals develop collections which meet sustainability goals and lower their institution's carbon footprint. 

Evaluation:

I was immediately intrigued by the idea of a 'Green Audit' for evaluating a publisher or collection's overall sustainability. I think libraries are often thought of as inherently 'green' or ecologically sustainable because providing access to resources like books cuts down on the overall material over-consumption of goods. While this may be true to some level, just being a 'more sustainable' option than individuals all buying their books does not guarantee that our overall collection is truly sustainable. I also have not come across many discussions of sustainability as it pertains to library collection development, even though environmental practices are becoming more important in other fields. I think the article overall provides an insightful, customizable evaluation technique to consider when planning collection development.

Library as an antidote to despair

Shannon Trawick

Discussion

When creating Partners in Health, an NGO dedicated to providing a medical ‘preferential option for the poor’ across the world, Dr. Paul Farmer put a little nugget of delight into his mission statement: “...serve as an antidote to despair.” When I read this, it struck me as applicable not only to needed medical treatment for the world’s impoverished, but to the impoverished level of hope, confidence, and imagination people the world over have in our current systems - political, economic, legal, environmental, etc. 

I suggest that the library, in its many forms, is an antidote to that despair.


We library workers are on the front lines of this despair in many forms, we see and interact with the full spectrum of the human condition on a daily basis and I posit that shifting our perspective on what we do as workers may help with burn out and open our minds to the help that a lot of our patrons really need. It’s not easy. I go into my two jobs everyday with the mindset that every person I encounter is at their worst - I’d rather be pleasantly surprised than disappointed. If I can, at best, give them some grace and help them solve a problem or direct them to a small antidote to their despair or, at worst, not engage with their behavior, address their issue and end the interaction, I’ve done my part and it doesn’t need to be any more than that.


I also know that it can be hard to remember how we alleviate despair since we’re in the thick of it all the time, so I’ve included some ways below that libraries do this for us and for our communities and I would encourage you to share these with anyone and everyone at any opportunity (I know I do).


In the library, there are so many antidotes to despair - and they’re all free!


  • Lonely? Attend a program or three. Maybe you don’t know anything about the topic, but you’ll learn something and meet people at the same time. In many programs, you aren’t even required to interact with other people if you don’t want to.

  • Un- or Underemployed? Use the free public computers connected to the internet to job search, apply for jobs, increase job skills through educational sites like Coursera or LinkedIn Learning, and search for other resources to help in your search like resume workshops (even if your library doesn’t have these, they’ll know who does).

  • Are your eyes, your heart, your soul asking you to stop the endless scrolling? 

    • May I introduce you to BOOKS? If we don’t have them all, we can likely get them for you at the library through Interlibrary Loans.
      If you can’t get to the library building, you can access digital books or sign up for a homebound patrons program which will deliver your desired books to you on a monthly basis. Some places will also offer Library by Mail where books are mailed to you with a return envelope.

    • Why not actually touch grass? Or make it? Because the library has seeds and gardening books that will let you experience the magic of putting your hands in the dirt. I don’t know what it is, but I know it’s there.

  • Has the economy hit (or never stopped hitting) your wallet?

    • Can’t afford streaming services? The library has DVDs and BluRays to borrow - welcome to the 21st century Blockbuster.

    • How about a place to hang out where you don’t have to buy anything to stay?

    • Want to visit parks and museums in your local area? I bet the library has some kind of pass program that gets you free entrance into some of these attractions that you can ask about.

    • Looking for crafts or something to keep your hands busy? Many libraries offer craft kits across all ages on a periodic basis. Also, many now have makerspaces with a variety of technology - engravers, 3D printers, sewing machines, glow forges, etc. - to up your making game.

    • Need a piece of equipment for ONE thing and don’t want to buy it? Been thinking about buying something but want to make sure you’ll actually use it more than once? Check to see if your library has a Library of Things where you can check out equipment and stuff - pressure washers, sewing machines, air fryers, instant pots, canning equipment, Cricuts, games, puzzles, tools - you name it, there is probably a library that can check it out to you. We also have books to explain how to best use a lot of the stuff in the Library of Things, just ask!


There’s more, there’s always more and I hope there always will be.


To end my saccharine screed, I’m going to leave you with this quote from organizer Miriam Kaba as it encompasses the praxis of being an antidote to despair, at least in my reading of it:

“Hope is a discipline. It’s less about 'how you feel,’ and more about the practice of making a decision every day, that you’re still gonna put one foot in front of the other, that you’re still going to get up in the morning… It’s work to be hopeful. It’s not like a fuzzy feeling… you have to actually put in energy, time, and you have to be clear-eyed, and you have to hold fast to having a vision. It’s a hard thing to maintain. But it matters to have it, to believe that it’s possible, to change the world…” (Kaba, 26-27)


In what ways are your libraries an antidote to despair?


_____________


Works Cited: 


Kaba, Mariame. We Do This 'Til We Free Us : Abolitionist Organizing and Transforming Justice. Chicago, Il, Haymarket Books, 23 Feb. 2021.


Saturday, May 9, 2026

Selecting and Evaluating Reference Materials

 Dennis McCormack

Hiremath, U., & Cassell, K. A. (2023). Chapter 19: Selecting and evaluating reference materials. In Reference and information services. (pp. 3-16) American Library Association.

Summary: This textbook covers the history and standards of reference work in libraries. Chapter 19 is specifically about how to draft and follow a collection development policy. The authors argue that the collection development process begins with knowing the user base. A public library must know the demographics they will be serving, while school libraries must know the curriculum that will be covered. After librarians have an idea of who might come through their doors they must then review peer reviewed sources for the best and newest materials. Materials must be judged based on traits like currency, authority, format, & cost. Some materials work better as online resources, such as databases or catalogs. Think anything that would be unrealistic to print or would be unruly to navigate on paper. Weeding the collection is also an important part of collection development, otherwise the shelves would be filled with damaged or out-of-date books. 

Evaluation: The textbook was well written and each of the ideas flowed well into the next. I ended up citing this book in most of the classes I took this semester. I have some of the more helpful chapters downloaded and may come back to it as a resource for further courses. The authors covered a lot of ground without being bogged down by jargon or going too far into the weeds. I recommend this reading as a good jumping off point to further research in building a state of the art collection. 

Thursday, May 7, 2026

Reimagining the Public Library to Reconnect the Community

Garcia, Luz

Ted (2020, March 17). Shamichael Hallman: Reimagining the Public Library to Reconnect the Community. TedxMemphis. [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JI2CLgq3LLk

Summary: This TED Talk was given by Shamichael Hallman, who explained how the library changed from the 1960s to 2020. Libraries provide not just books to help with reports, but also technology access, public resources, student clubs, all-age programs, and safe spaces. Libraries connect communities; they are a bridge for the many people who come in and use the resources within the library. The library needs to become a safe space for different people to use, and we, as the library, need to change and provide what the community might lack. The library needs to adapt to the community's needs by providing study rooms, first-aid classes, after-school programs, or Summer activities for students. Also, to be aware of the community the library is in, and not to let marginalized communities block others from using the safe space the library provides.

Evaluation: Hallman's statement is correct: public libraries are now the main community centers they were before. Many people from different backgrounds come to the library to use its resources to improve their situation or to participate in a library activity. This is what public libraries are for: helping the community in any way possible and providing resources they can use to improve their living situations or personal lives. Public libraries are safe spaces for the community to socialize with one another and being able to speak freely with everyone.

Archival Outreach & Repairing Community Representation and Relationships

 Paige, Kaitlyn

Source 

Luster, D. (2018). Archives Have the Power to Boost Marginalized Voices. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XsNPlBBi1IE

Summary

This is a seminar given by Dominique Luster, she talks about the concept of who should control and what goes into the archives collections. She wants her listeners to think about how materials are portrayed and how they are received by a multitude of audiences. Are we as archivists taking the living people or culture out of the history and sterilizing it to make it more palatable to western peoples. Luster profoundly states, "If your history wasn’t recorded or preserved well; did you exist?" She questions the concept of who should decide what should go into the archives and how they should decide how it is portrayed to people outside the community it serves. There is an unmistakable connection between these items that were given or more often stolen from these communities that an outsider would not necessarily understand. Ultimately, the members of that community who express interest in collection materials should have a say in how these materials are brought to the light or taken back and adopted back into the communities culture. She explains that there is a power struggle between the concept of Bias vs. Privilege, this centers around colonialism and gentrification of materials in the archival collections. The last idea she brings up is the concept of who is truly the expert on these materials, their stories, and how they are being displayed if they are displayed? This centers around the direct battle between archivists and the native communities. Luster ends the discussion with a new archival theory that is racially conscience and has culturally competent practices; this includes asking questions about dis/ability, age, appearance, empowerment, ethnicity / race / nationality, gender / sex / sexuality, health and letting the community answer in a way  that creates a bridge of outreach between archivists and the communities they want to serve. When we give the power to the people and let them teach and be an active part of the archives, all parties grow, open communication flourishes, and archives become a place of true neutral ground.

Evaluation

This declaration makes one wonder if the way we have been receiving information and using martials in archives is one minded (colonial minded) and why no one has challenged this major way of gaining / labeling / displaying information in archives. Many patrons of archives and adjoining entities like libraries and museums have been fed the colonial mindset and have commonly accepted it at face value because this is the way that has always been taught for decades. It has taken up until the last 15 years for people both in the information field and underserved communities to speak up and demand the change from western to DEI / feminist practices. This starts with outreaching and open communication between the two entities. Luster practically begs the audience of archivists to ask the community how they would like to be perceived, showcased, and remembered and urges them to work with them to achieve a better received collection that gives these materials the right labels and respect in addition to giving a voice back to the communities. During this class I brought up the idea of creating a living archival collection between the John M. Pfau library and the Office of Tribal Affairs on the library’s Native American history collection. It is in reviewing the outreach between the two organizations that I can say that the library has already started the ground work. The library lets the OTA review and submit requests on materials for weeding or making new additions. This gives the Native Peoples a voice in how they would like to be perceived and a way for the tribal Elders to have an active hand in repairing the harm done by colonialism in academic archives and libraries, entities that have a long history of stealing and harming Native life. The next step in this process would have elected members from the Native community physically come into the library and become part of the team that actively participates in the collections handling and growth on a daily basis. More archives should start the practice and outreach and try to repair the damage done by the past.


Considering Building a Collection? Consider Civic Engagement First.

Joshua Chacon

Wray‐Lake, L., & Abrams, L. S. (2020). Pathways to Civic Engagement Among Urban Youth of Color. Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development, 85(2), 7–154. https://doi.org/10.1111/mono.12415

Summary:

Pathways to Civic Engagement Among Urban Youth of Color by Laura Wray-Lake and Laura S. Abrams is a 154-page monograph detailing youth perspectives on civic engagement and related social and political topics. Within this text, the authors focus on civic engagement and empowerment, marginalized youth perspectives on social, cultural, and political issues, and the consistent disempowerment of youth of color within the context of a white dominated society. The monograph is extremely dedicated to exploring its single core question, which is clearly stated by the researchers: “What does civic engagement look like and how does it develop for urban youth of color living in high poverty neighborhoods?” (Wray-Lake & Abrams, 2020, p. 10). Despite the evidence of continued marginalization of minorities within Rochester, New York, and the historical context given in chapter 1, the researchers take a nondirectional approach with their thesis in order to explore factors that both hinder and promote civic engagement: Assets, opportunities, and personal experiences affect youth of color’s civic engagement and their perspectives on local and federal political and social issues.

My Comments:

The qualitative methods used in this monograph have great foundational opportunities for evaluating library services and programs. Firstly, the qualitative analysis within the monograph is a collaborative effort between youth and the researchers, often balancing conclusions and insights from both parties in order to solidify ideas. Libraries can benefit from this because it empowers youth voices, granting them weight in library decisions. Secondly, the insights given by the researchers often highlight the importance of “informal engagement.” Libraries could create spaces to explore these types of expressions and begin hosting more youth-led initiatives and activities. This could also lead to new programs that help increase and study these types of youth behaviors, learning new ways to identify the indicators “that would provide data about observable behaviors and conditions” (Wray, 2012, p. 50).

One thing to be wary about concerning this methodological approach is the limitation of sampling. Much like youth centers, libraries will have youth who are already engaged in some civic participation. This is a safe assumption considering that youth who willingly participate within civic institutions must have more motivation to be civically engaged. Libraries’ outreach strategies must tackle the participation gap by reaching out to individuals who are disconnected civic institutions.